How to run an RFP for an HOA manager and what to compare in proposals
What an RFP is
A request for proposals (RFP) is a short package that tells management firms about your association and asks them to price and describe their services in the same format. You don't need a 30-page legal document. Two pages of facts plus a list of questions works for most associations.
Step 1: Form a small selection committee
Two or three directors, or a board member plus a trusted owner with finance or contracting experience, can run the process. Decide up front how the committee will report and who votes. Idaho boards may discuss hiring, bid review and contract negotiation in executive session by majority vote, but board actions still belong in the minutes (Idaho Code 55-3204). If any committee member has a relationship with a bidder, disclose it; the Act requires directors to declare conflicts of interest at the annual meeting.
Step 2: Write down what you need
Collect these basics:
- Association name, location, number of homes, and common amenities
- Current budget and monthly assessment level
- Current manager, if any, and contract end date (do not share more than you need to)
- Meeting needs: how many board meetings and annual meetings, and whether you want the manager attending in person
- Services wanted: bookkeeping and financial reports, billing and collections, violation inspections and letters, architectural request handling, vendor bidding and oversight, owner communications, website or portal
- Start date you want, and your decision timeline
Attach governing documents and the most recent financials if you are comfortable doing so; many boards share these once a firm signs a simple confidentiality note.
Step 3: Send the same package to each firm
Invite two to four firms, including your current manager if you are open to keeping them. Set one deadline and one contact person for questions, and share any answer with all bidders so none has an advantage. Ask them to price the same scope so proposals can be compared directly.
Step 4: Compare proposals side by side
Put each proposal in a table. Compare:
- Base fee: monthly cost, and what it covers.
- Extra charges: violation letters, collections, special assessments, project management, additional meetings, after-hours calls, mailing and copies, website fees, transfer or onboarding fees.
- Staffing: named contact, how many associations that person manages, backup coverage.
- Financial handling: accounts in the association's name, reporting frequency, who approves payments, insurance and fidelity coverage.
- Technology: owner portal, online payments, work-order tracking, document storage.
- Response times: the firm's stated standard for owners and boards, and how they measure it.
- Contract terms: length, auto-renewal, termination notice, fees at termination, and who owns the records. (See our guide on switching managers.)
- Local knowledge: experience with Treasure Valley city requirements, irrigation districts, and similar associations.
- References: at least two current client boards.
The lowest base fee is not always the lowest total cost. Ask each firm to estimate your annual cost using the same sample year, including typical extras.
Step 5: Interviews and references
Interview your top two or three. Ask them to walk through a typical month for an association like yours, how they handle a delinquent account, and how they handle a disagreement between the manager and the board. Call references and ask about responsiveness, accuracy of financial reports, and how the firm handled mistakes.
Step 6: Decide, document, and negotiate
Score the finalists, discuss as a board, and vote. Record the decision in the minutes. Before signing, read the agreement closely (and get professional review if you are unsure), and negotiate anything unclear: notice periods, price increase caps, and records return.
A simple scoring sheet (suggested weights are examples)
| Category | Weight | Firm A | Firm B | Firm C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total estimated annual cost | 25% | |||
| Services match | 20% | |||
| Staffing and responsiveness | 20% | |||
| Financial controls and reporting | 15% | |||
| Contract terms | 10% | |||
| References | 10% |